
Unverified Listing
This profile was automatically curated for our directory and has not yet been claimed by the business. Information and pricing may be out of date. If you own this business, please claim this listing to update your details.
About Carfagna's Catering
Carfagna's Catering is a luxury caterers based in Columbus, Ohio.
At a Glance
- Experience: 30+ years in the industry.
- Pricing: Premium services in the $$ tier.
- Location: Available for local travel.
For over three decades, Carfagna's Catering has been a cherished culinary institution in Central Ohio, bringing authentic flavors and heartfelt hospitality to life's most momentous celebrations. Renowned for their exquisite homemade Italian specialties and comprehensive event execution, this family-owned caterer transforms weddings into unforgettable gastronomic experiences. From custom menu design down to the finest tablescape details, their seasoned professionals ensure every reception is executed with effortless elegance.
Offerings & Bespoke Services:
- Wedding buffet and family-style catering
- Custom Italian wedding dinner packages
- Appetizer cocktail hour displays
- Beverage and alcohol packages
- Event staffing and tableware rentals
Services & Experience Packages
- βWedding buffet and family-style catering
- βCustom Italian wedding dinner packages
- βAppetizer cocktail hour displays
- βBeverage and alcohol packages
- βEvent staffing and tableware rentals
Services Overview
| Feature | Details |
|---|---|
| Service Category | Caterers |
| Coverage Area | Local Events |
| Experience Level | 30+ Years |
| Response Time | 3-5 Business Days |
Aesthetic & Style Tags
Portfolio Gallery




Location
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the starting price for Carfagna's Catering?
Carfagna's Catering offers services in the $$ pricing tier. For exact quotes and bespoke packages, please request pricing and availability directly.
Where is Carfagna's Catering located?
Carfagna's Catering is located in Columbus, Ohio.
Does Carfagna's Catering travel for weddings?
Yes, Carfagna's Catering has a travel policy that covers local events only.
How much experience does Carfagna's Catering have?
Carfagna's Catering has over 30 years of professional experience in the wedding industry, specializing in luxury events.
How do I book Carfagna's Catering for my wedding?
You can inquire about booking Carfagna's Catering by using the "Check Availability" form on this profile to contact them directly regarding your wedding date and vision.
Why choose Carfagna's Catering as your wedding caterers?
Carfagna's Catering is a verified luxury wedding professional known for exceptional service and bespoke experiences. Their portfolio and expertise make them a highly sought-after choice for discerning couples.
Google Reviews
Unfortunately, our overall dining experience was disappointing. The appetizers and pesto dishes were the highlights of our meal and were the only items that had the flavor and quality we expected. However, the rest of the food we ordered was extremely bland and lacked the seasoning and attention to detail we anticipated. The bread was also a major disappointment. It was hard as a rock and had an unpleasant fermented smell, as if it had been left to sit too long. I do want to recognize that our server was phenomenal. She was attentive, professional, and provided excellent service throughout our visit. Unfortunately, the quality of the food was not enough to bring us back, and we will not be returning. We hope the restaurant can use this feedback to improve consistency and the overall dining experience for future guests.
Get ready to ...relax into your meal. Expect a relaxed pace. The decore is nice, atmosphere nice. They have a variety of items available. There are glutem feee options. The pepperoni is the crispy kind which is great. My son said the sandwich as a bit dry. The other son thought the pizza was ok. The old fashion I had was strong and they smoked it at the table. The place has a nice market and large wine shop. Stop over when you get a chance
Fantastic food from the restaurant. Real, REAL delicious Italian food. From appetizer to canolli and biscotti. The entrees are awesome. Give it a try. Don't often give 5 stars!!
nd bar skills are fantastic. Every drink he made a fantastic! Good ambiance and service however thatβs where it stops! Food service has fallen off which is sad. Appetizers; provolone wedges and calamari. The seasoning and breading on calamari was great, canβt say the same for the wedges. Both dishes were just warm. 1st course; garden salad- pretty standard and good! EntrΓ©e 30 minutes later my guest looked at watched questioning our dishes. Honestly Iβm not sure why it would have been platted and even brought out the way it looked. Three people pre-say looked at these dishes (chef, expo & bartender) and thought it was acceptable to bring to table- astonishing! The veal parmigiana was burn to entire crispy just remarkable brunt! Once cutting off all the crust and eating the veal alone it was great. Ben agreed it was brunt and would make another but keep in mind it would take additional 15 minutes. Not acceptable timing with another guess waiting to eat. He asked someone and they took 50% off veal. Bacon Wrapped Filet; cooked M/R was undercooked at rare but that was great truthfully! I like them both! Unfortunately they failed again by leaving the plastic string on the filet - Ben apologized and said they should have taken it off. The side of fettuccine and noddles was cold and asparagus was warm. Very disappointing especially after the time waited. Meals werenβt as describe; cold, burnt or looked anything like all the pictures you have posted all around restaurant. After all this I still tried my hand at dessert with the Lemon Bomb- best thing coming from kitchen at this point. So $250 (including $50 tip) later with below average food but good customer service Iβm not sure if Iβll return for anything other drinks here. Very disappointing and kitchen failed today! Maybe I need to figure out what day the head chef is back there to order Ben said he wasnβt there today. Iβm actually surprised with all the issues going on that the manager didnβt make an appearance once!
Nice restaurant. Great food! Kind atmosphere. Thereβs a grocery store attached which is very interesting to shop afterwards. Definitely a must go to if you havenβt already. Bruschetta is delish. Salad was good. Too much dressing for my liking so Iβll ask for dressing on the side next time. Meatball tasted homemade and received great feedback. The butternut squash ravioli was the best Iβve ever had. Amazing!
Pricing Guide
Inquire with Carfagna's Catering
Inquiry Submitted!
Thank you. Carfagna's Catering will review your date and respond promptly.